Mrs Monk Her Life and Times


Music and Movies


Leigh On Sea

Other Places & Architecture

unmade films

GO TO   2010 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2004

JenaDesigns for Building Plans on CAD for House Extensions and Planning Permission




Mrs. Monk's Would-be Diary, should have been written by Mrs. Monk, since she is the "Writer" in the family.
However, since she is a writer only in the conceptual sense, I have undertaken to fill these pages on her behalf.
If not by her, these pages will certainly be about her, and other important matters of the day

Leslie Monk



Site Stats

Contact.........   SHOESTRINGONLINE

Comment,  complain, or applaud these pages, or  be added to the mailing list


Unmade Films .........

Film or Novel?

The novel has been replaced.

I exaggerate maybe, but the few novels which get published, including those which receive critical acclaim, are hardly read. A best seller might expect a readership of say; 200,000. A black and white classic film, recycled on a wet Sunday afternoon on the BBC, might measure it's audience in millions.

The novel does just survive, as a kind of marketing tool for the film industry. "The film of the book", we are told and not always truthfully, because they know, after all, that we don't really care about the book.

Since novelists are better known than novels, an association of a particular film, with a particular author is more useful as film promotion, than an association with the book itself. I, for one, have never read a Stephen King novel, but I more or less know what to expect, from a film bearing his name.

A movie is unlikely to follow a novelist's plot, let alone the texture, or even the meaning of the work. (And neither should it, of course.) Coppola's film of Dracula sets itself apart from other Dracula's by calling itself, "Bram Stoker's Dracula". Bram Stoker is no longer a best-selling author and is hardly well known, (if he ever was), but we are invited to think that this particular Dracula has some classy literary credentials, and furthermore, that it is faithful to the book. (I, for one, was fooled.)

The novelist sells a film by default. Ian Fleming is no longer with us, but Ian Fleming's James Bond is alive and well-shaken and re-stirred, again and again.

The merit of a novelist is not here, at issue; there are good and bad novels, but there are few relevant novels.

Enlightened story tellers are now called screenwriters, and  screenwriters do not have the last word.

We are grateful for the notable exceptions, the nuggets of cinema culture: the inimitable Woody Allen maybe, though one doubts if his "auteur" status would stand, were he merely a writer. Other artful survivors like Robert Altman, and Martin Scorcese are of course not writers per se. Credit is more likely to be given to a worthy director than to a brilliant writer.

As the novel declines, the language of the novelist evolves, in terms of the influence of the film culture.

Novels are often written commercially, with cinema adaptation in mind, but even obscure novels, with no such ambition, are measured against the evolving cinematic language, and the evolution is out of their control, forever.  

Sam Hutt     


[Home] [Mrs Monk] [Photography] [Music and Movies] [Art] [Leigh] [Other Places] [Recommended] [go back] [Hippo] [Unmade] [Manifesto]

GO BACK 2010 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2004

 Shoestringonline Video Channel on YOUTube

 Shoestringonline Video Channel on Vimeo

 Shoestringonline Photostream On FlikR

 Movies Created by Monks on Vimeo